AI secretary vs a hired receptionist
Total monthly cost at different workloads. The AI secretary costs 3% of a receptionist at small-business load and 50% even when the receptionist is fully used on calls, while covering 24/7 and taking several calls at once. Calls are set against two AI receptionists, and messages against three of the best AI support agents on the market.
Try a workload
What it hands to your staff: judgment calls, upset callers and anyone at the counter.
Calls, against AI receptionists
Messages, against the top AI agents
Answering: Esek against hiring
| Workload per month | Esek | Receptionist | Answering service |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small5 calls + 5 chats a day · 275 min, 110 conversations | ₪295 | ₪10,400half time ≈ ₪5,200 | ₪539 |
| Busy clinic20 calls + 15 chats a day · 1,100 min, 330 conversations | ₪1,210 | ₪10,400 | ₪2,180 |
| Very busy50 calls + 40 chats a day · 2,750 min, 880 conversations | ₪3,058 | ₪20,8002 people: calls + chats | ₪5,464 |
| Receptionist fully usedphone only · 6,500 talk min | ₪5,192 | ₪10,400 | ₪12,926 |
| 24/7 coveragebusy-clinic load | ₪1,210 | ₪46,000 to 50,0004.4 full-time staff | not offered |
Answering service: the published packages of a leading Israeli answering service, ₪469 for 240 minutes then ₪1.99 a minute; Sunday to Thursday 8:00 to 23:00; calls only, no chats.
Calls: Esek against AI receptionists
| Calls per month | Esek | Competitor A | Competitor B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small5 calls a day · 110 calls, 275 min | ₪229 | ₪800 | ₪428 |
| Busy clinic20 calls a day · 440 calls, 1,100 min | ₪926 | ₪2,667 | ₪1,178 |
| Very busy50 calls a day · 1,100 calls, 2,750 min | ₪2,230 | ₪6,673 | ₪2,677 |
| Receptionist fully used2,600 calls, 6,500 min | ₪5,192 | ₪15,777 | ₪6,084 |
Competitor A, a well-known US AI receptionist, prices by the call, whatever its length: free for 25 calls then $3 a call; $150 for 75 calls then $2; $500 for 300 calls then $1.67. Competitor B, a US AI front desk: $99 for 200 minutes then $0.25 a minute. Esek's AI phone line is free.
Messages: Esek against the top AI agents
| Conversations per month | Esek | Competitor C | Competitor D | Competitor E |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small5 customers a day · 110 conversations | ₪66 | ₪501 | ₪1,014 | ₪800 |
| Busy clinic15 customers a day · 330 conversations | ₪284 | ₪1,293 | ₪2,613 | ₪2,399 |
| Very busy40 customers a day · 880 conversations | ₪828 | ₪3,272 | ₪6,611 | ₪6,397 |
| Very high volume200 customers a day · 4,400 conversations | ₪4,313 | ₪15,937 | ₪32,197 | ₪31,983 |
These are the AI agents of three leading customer-support platforms, used by large support teams and connected through the official messaging channels. Competitor C: $0.99 per resolved conversation plus one $29 seat. Competitor D: $2.00 per automated resolution after 5 included, plus one $69 seat. Competitor E: $2.00 per conversation.
C and D bill only conversations their AI resolves; the figures assume every conversation resolves, their maximum. At a 60% resolution rate, C's very-high-volume month is about ₪9,600, still more than twice Esek. An Esek conversation is everything one customer writes in a day, so a back-and-forth over hours is still one.
Calling leads
| Workload per month | Esek | Competitor A | Competitor B | Junior telemarketer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Manual dialing at full capacityabout 2,000 talk min | ₪1,68013% | not offered | capped20 calls a day | ₪13,300 |
| With an auto-dialer at full capacityabout 7,400 talk min | ₪5,94645% | not offered | capped20 calls a day | ₪13,300 |
Competitor A answers only. Competitor B dials out, but its standard plan stops at 20 calls a day, far below a telemarketer's load; above that it quotes. Esek charges these minutes at the same call price, on the same balance, from the first call, with no daily cap.
What you get for the money
| Esek | Hired receptionist | |
|---|---|---|
| Hours covered | 24/7, about 168 h a week | about 42 h a week (25%) |
| Calls at the same time | Several | One |
| After hours, or while on another call | Answered | Missed or voicemail |
| Cost per handled call, busy clinic | about ₪2.10 | about ₪23.60 |
| Sick days, holidays, turnover | None | Yes, plus recruiting and training |
| Judgment, upset callers, walk-ins | Handed to staff | Better |
Assumptions
- Esek prices from November 2026: messages ₪0.99 per conversation with one customer per day; call minutes ₪0.99 and ₪0.79 by monthly volume (1 to 500, 501 and up), all calls together. Free every week: 10 message conversations and 10 AI secretary call minutes. The AI phone line is free.
- Calls on 22 working days a month; 4.33 weeks a month.
- Receptionist ₪8,200 gross, about ₪10,400 to the employer (pension, severance, national insurance, recreation pay, travel). One person handles about 6,500 talk minutes a month at 80% occupancy. The telemarketer figure includes commission.
- Dollar prices are converted at ₪3.08 plus 18% VAT, so every AI and service price on this page includes VAT; employer costs carry none. A VAT-registered business reclaims the 18%, so its real cost for any of the AI options is about 15% lower than shown.
- Staff are sized by calls and messages together: one person handles about 6,500 talk minutes or about 1,150 chat conversations a month at full pace (the top of the 660 to 1,150 benchmark), and the two loads add up.
- Competitor prices are as published on 4 October 2026. We don't name other companies.